Title: AIDC / sequencing table inconsistent with state tables PDR Reference: 97060024 Originator Reference: Logica/DF/AIDC/009 SARPs Document Reference: AIDC SARPs ICAO, Version 1.1, section 3.2.10 Status: ACCEPTED PDR Revision Date: 27/06/97 PDR Submission Date: 27/06/97 Submitting State/Organization: Submitting Author Name: Fieldhouse, Dirk Submitting Author E-mail Address: fieldhouse@logica.com Submitting Author Supplemental Contact Information: Logica UK Limited 75 Hampstead Road London NW1 2PL UK +44 (171) 637 9111 SARPs Date: ICAO Version 1.1 (ATNP/WGW1), March 1997 SARPs Language: english Summary of Defect: 1) The sequence number for the paragraph following 3.2.10.2 is 3.1.10.2.1 and should be 3.2.10.2.1. 2) Table 3.2.10-1 (Service Primitive Sequencing) is inconsistent with the text of the SARPs. For instance, the End primitive can be submitted in the Coordinating phase. 3) More fundamentally, the requirement in 3.2.10.2.1 is not independent of the remainder of the SARPs. The sequencing shown in Table 3.2.10.2-1 is enforced by the AIDC-AE if the AIDC-ASE conforms to the SARPs 3.2.6. Assigned SME: Sub-Volume 3 SME Proposed SARPs amendment: For 1): Change paragraph number to 3.2.10.2.1. For 2): Table 3.2.10-1 needs to be revised based on a thorough analysis of the text in the remainder of the SARPs. For 3): The requirement in 3.2.10.2.1 should either be expressed as a requirement on the AIDC-User (ie, in 3.2.9), or placed in the GM, or reworded for inclusion in 3.2.3.3 as follows: "3.2.3.3.n The AIDC service primitives shall conform to the sequencing rules shown in Table 3.2.3-1. Note.- The AIDC AE enforces the sequencing rules. <>" SME Recommendation to CCB: CCB Decision: